The Branchville Agency is proud to represent nine of the leading competitors in the insurance industry. Each of our carriers offer unique policies. One of our agents will work with you to gain the coverage you need with the best possible value.

In addition to our main nine insurance carriers, we also have a number of specialty insurance companies that provide coverage for Mobile Homes, Motor Homes & Travel Trailer, Watercraft, Personal Watercraft, Collector Auto, Motorcycle, Snowmobile, Directors & Officers, Professional Liability and Special Automobile Insurance Plan (Dollar-A-Day) Personal Automobile.

Our agents are available by appointment from 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Monday through Friday to quote your policy and help you find the right insurance carrier to suit all your personal and commercial needs. Call our office at 973-948-3110 to set up an appointment to meet with one of our agents today!

You can visit the links below any time to make payments and claims.

Franklin Mutual Insurance (Branchville, NJ)
FMI offers complete insurance for: Homeowners, Dwelling Fire, Tenant, House of Worship, Personal Excess, and Business Owners.

Selective Insurance (Branchville, NJ)
Selective Insurance provides Home, Dwelling Fire, Tenant, Business Owners, Special Contractors, Worker's Compensation, Mid/Large Commercial Lines and Bonds.

Farmers Insurance of Flemington (Flemington, NJ)
Farmers Insurance offers Home, Dwelling Fire, Tenant, Business Owners, Special Contractors and Artisian Contractors.

Plymouth Rock (Berkeley Heights, NJ)
Plymouth Rock offers auto insurance quotes for New Jersey.

Travelers (Glen Falls, NY)
Travelers offers clients full insurance coverage in Home, Tenant, Dwelling Fire, Personal Excess, Personal Auto and has recently introduced the Wedding Protection Plan.

Progressive (Mayfield Village, OH)
Progressive Insurance provides Personal Auto, Stand Alone Commercial Auto and Motorcycle.

Fidelity National Property & Casualty Insurance Company (Jacksonville, FL)
Fidelity provides homeowners and personal umbrella insurance.

Mercury Insurance (Bridgewater, NJ)
Providers of Home, Condo, Renters, Personal Umbrella, Automobile and Mechanical Breakdown Protection. Mechanical Breakdown Protection is similar to Automobile Warranty coverage. Its protection features provide coverage as follows:

  • Provides 24-hour Roadside Assistance
  • Rental Vehicle Assistance
  • Tire Protection
  • Trip Interruption Coverage
  • Nationwide Protection
  • Repairs can be done at any Licensed US Repair Facility
  • There is no limit to number of claims you can make
  • Coverage is Transferrable to New owner, should you sell your car

ProGuard® offered through our partner agency, Powderhorn Agency - offers residential oil heat customers protection for underground and aboveground oil storage tanks and lines.

ProSept® offered through our partner agency, Powderhorn Agency - offers residential customers with Septic Tanks peace of mind for all components of a septic system. It is the first and only insurance-backed residential septic system program that helps eliminate concerns over possibility of tens of thousands of dollars in repair or replacement costs in the event of a system malfunction.

Cumberland Group (Bridgeton, NJ)
Cumberland Group has offered Personal and Business insurance since 1844. Cumberland offers a variety of Personal lines business: Homeowners, Combination Dwellings, Tenant (Renter’s insurance), Condominiums, Personal Automobile (available in PA only), and Personal Umbrellas.

Cumberland’s commercial niche market is Restaurants, Small Artisan Contractors, General Liability, Property, Commercial Automobile, Workers Compensation and Umbrella insurance.

Teachers of NJ, A Plymouth Rock Company (Red Bank, NJ)

Founded in 2007, NJ's educational community deserves to be recognized for all of their selfless contributions. That's why we're proud to offer auto insurance exclusively to this important group of people!

Our special rates are meant for NJ residents who work for or are retired from an accredited school, district or diocese, plus members of the New Jersey Parent Teacher Association (NJPTA). For a full list of eligibility, visit

Beyond huge savings, Teachers’ Insurance offers specialized programs and services like our Quotes for Cash® program to help raise funds for your school district, School Zone Zero deductibles, First Class Roadside Assistance, Get Home Safe complimentary cab rides, Door to Door Valet Claim ServiceSM, Crashbusters® mobile claim vehicles and more!



 Insurance Products | Insurance Carriers | Branchville Agency News | Online Insurance Payments | Antiques and Classic Car Collections
©Branchville Agency  |  Website by