Hours of Operation
Monday through Friday 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
(24 hour emergency service available)

Call or email us today to schedule an appointment with one of our agents for an Insurance Quote!

973-948-3110 phone
973-948-2796 fax

4 Wantage Avenue
PO Box 2398
Branchville, New Jersey 07826

Email us - General Information


Or email our friendly and helpful Staff:

  • Daryl Haggerty - Agent / Principal

    Daryl joined the family insurance agency in 1994. A native of Culver Lake, Daryl developed his insurance experience taking advantage of his combined prior tenure in the marine, automobile and foodservice industries. Daryl draws on this prior experience and his passion for cars and boats in assisting business and personal clients in acquiring the best possible insurance protection for their individual needs.
  • George B. Harper - Agent / Principal

    George has been an insurance agent in Sussex County for over 40 years.  He built the Tri-State Insurance Agency from just himself to a 20 person agency, eventually selling that agency to a local bank in 2001.  After leaving the bank in 2009 he purchased the RC Lain Agency in Port Jervis NY and since 2016 George has been a principal in the Branchville Agency.  George is a customer focused and brings his 40 years of experience in assisting clients with all their insurance needs.  George is licensed in NJ, NY and PA.
  • Susan Gay - Personal Lines Account Manager

    Susan has been handling Personal Lines Insurance for more than 10 years and was previously in the Life and Health Insurance business. She has a Bachelor of Business Administration degree and holds a professional designation as Certified Insurance Service Representative. She has lived in Sussex County for 23 years and currently resides in Wantage. She enjoys explaining coverages and helping you make informed decisions on your Auto, Home, Jewelry, Boat and other personal insurance policies
  • Sue Howell- Commercial Lines Account Manager
  • Sue comes to our office with an extensive background, of more than 25 years of commercial insurance experience. She has a Bachelor Degree in Music Education. Born and raised in Andover NJ, she has lived in Pittsburgh PA and ten years in Champaign-Urbana, IL.  She first became a licensed agent while working in Illionois.  After moving back to Andover, NJ she obtained her NJ Producers Insurance License and continues to work in the commercial side of insurance.  Sue earned the Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR) designation from the Society of Certified Insurance Service Representatives and take continuing education classes throughout the year. She looks forward to working with you on your commercial insurance needs.

  • AnnMarie Cieplinski - Administrative Assistant / Billing

    AnnMarie, a 20 year resident of Milford PA., is our customer support representative and underwriting assistant. AnnMarie’s friendly voice or smiling face will be the first to welcome you to The Branchville Agency experience. With over 16 years of Property & Casualty Insurance experience, she is available to assists you with billing questions or concerns, claims and certificate requests, along with so much more!

After hours emergency calls: 973-670-1288



 Insurance Products | Insurance Carriers | Branchville Agency News | Online Insurance Payments | Antiques and Classic Car Collections
©Branchville Agency  |  Website by